Cafe Pie Menu

Plated Breakfasts

  • Regular Full English

    $

  • Large Full English

    $

  • Ultimate Full English

    $

Breakfasts Specials

  • Creamy Mushrooms On Toast Served With Dressed Salad Leaves

    $

  • Smoked Kippers Served With Parsley Butter, Lemon And Toast

    $

  • Smoked Salmon And Scrambled Eggs Served With Lemon And Toast

    $

  • Full English Breakfast Omelette Served With Mixed Dressed Salad And Toast

    $

Hot Sandwiches

  • Bacon

    $

  • Sausage

    $

  • Bacon & Egg

    $

  • Sausage & Egg

    $

  • Bacon & Sausage

    $

  • Bacon & Tomato

    $

  • Sausage & Tomato

    $

  • Bacon & Mushroom

    $

  • Sausage & Mushroom

    $

  • Bacon, Sausage & Egg

    $

  • Bacon, Egg & Tomato

    $

  • Bacon, Egg, Sausage & Tomato

    $

Cafe Pie Favourites

  • Pork Sausage Served With Homemade Mash, Garden Peas And Onion Gravy

    $

  • Quiche Of The Day Served With Chips, Dressed Mixed Salad And Homemade Coleslaw

    $

  • Chicken Burger Served With Chips, Dressed Mixed Salad And Homemade Coleslaw

    $

Sides

  • Chips

    $

  • Mashed Potatoes

    $

  • Red Cabbage

    $

  • Mushy Peas

    $

  • Broccoli

    $

  • Gravy

    $

  • Bread Cake

    $

  • Bread And Butter

    $

Jacket Potatoes

  • Beans

    $

  • Cheese

    $

  • Tuna Mayo

    $

  • Chicken Curry

    $

  • Spicy Bean Casserole

    $

Hot Drinks

  • Mug Of Yorkshire Tea

    $

  • Pot Of Yorkshire Tea

    $

  • Americano

    $

  • Cappuccino

    $

  • Latte

    $

  • Mocha

    $

  • Hot Chocolate

    $

  • Nescafe

    $

  • Cans

    $

Cold Sandwiches

  • Ham

    $

  • Mature Cheddar Cheese

    $

  • Egg Mayo

    $

  • Tuna Mayo

    $

  • Chicken Breast

    $

Others

  • Ham

    $

  • Mature Cheddar

    $

  • Chicken Breast

    $
Image Not Found

The Cafe Pie Menu at 382-384 South Rd, Sheffield S6 3TF, United Kingdom, is a delightful showcase of British comfort food with a modern twist. As someone who appreciates hearty, home-style meals, this café exceeded expectations in both variety and quality.

The first standout is the range of pies - the heart of the menu. From traditional options like Steak & Ale and Chicken & Mushroom to more inventive choices such as Vegan Sweet Potato & Spinach, each pie is crafted with a buttery, flaky crust and generously filled. The fillings are rich, seasoned well, and cooked to tender perfection. The Steak & Ale in particular offers a deep, malty gravy and chunks of beef that melt in the mouth, making it a top contender for best traditional pie in Sheffield.

What enhances the experience further is the thoughtful pairing of sides. The creamy mashed potatoes, minted peas, and proper onion gravy served with most mains elevate the meal beyond expectations. You can also opt for chunky chips if you’re craving a classic British pub-style feel.

Beyond pies, the menu caters to a wide audience with lighter options like fresh salads and artisan sandwiches, ideal for a quick lunch. Breakfast lovers aren’t left out either-Cafe Pie offers a full English breakfast that’s both hearty and satisfying, making it a favorite for early risers.

Portion sizes are generous, and pricing is reasonable, especially considering the quality of ingredients. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, happy to guide first-timers through their best-sellers or dietary options.

Compared to chain pie shops or larger gastropubs, what makes the Cafe Pie Menu unique is its focus on scratch-made pies, comforting British flavors, and genuine hospitality. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this café is a must-visit for pie lovers.